Advarsel: Denne artikkelen inneholder spoilere gjennom denne ukens episode avDu bør ringe Saul.
Du bør ringe Saulhar bare én episode igjen i sin første sesong, og hovedpersonene er ved psykologiske vendepunkter. Jimmy har nettopp oppdaget brorens svik, Chuck har tatt små skritt for å komme tilbake på jobb, og Mike dypper tærne inn i Albuquerques kriminelle underverden.
Hvordan vil dynamikken deres endre seg når Jimmy McGill tar skritt mot å bli Saul Goodman? Vi snakket med Dr. Paul R. Puri, en psykiater og TV-skribent basert i Los Angeles, for å analysere Chucks bedring, Jimmys nye vei og Mikes teori om det kriminelle sinnet.
I løpet av sesongen har vi sett Chuck forlate hjemmet sitt og bli mer uavhengig. Er dette en realistisk fremstilling av bedring?
Jeg vil si at det er det. Det er mange faktorer som forventning spiller i forverringen av [tilstanden hans]. Når han ikke legger merke til det, er han faktisk ikke like symptomatisk, eller ikke symptomatisk i det hele tatt. Når han faktisk utsetter seg for det og blir med det, er ikke symptomene like ille. Det er veldig konsistent med hva det antas å være, som er noe vi nå kaller en somatisk symptomlidelse, som har egenskaper som ligner på en angstlidelse hvor unngåelse og forventning spiller store roller.
Vi ser at Chuck fokuserer på jobb, og det hjalp ham til å føle seg bedre. Handler det om distraksjonen, eller handler det om at han snur en ny side i sin personlighet?
Det er forskjellige linser for å se Chuck. En av dem erDSM, som egentlig ikke snakker om hvordan ting blir bedre. Og så er det forskjellige skoler for psykoterapi. Når han er i forskjellige roller, kan han på en måte benytte seg av høyere fungerende ferdigheter eller aspekter ved seg selv. Og så når han går inn i arbeidsmodus, når han blir engasjert i det, griper han inn i en versjon av seg selv som ikke er redd eller lever i frykt eller noe sånt.
Hvorfor løy Chuck for Jimmy så lenge mens han også var avhengig av ham?
Det er interessant. De har et komplekst forhold, og det ser ut til at Chuck, akkurat fra det vi har sett, til en viss grad ser på Jimmy som farlig, og seg selv som litt av en verge, den eldre broren, den som trenger å holde ham unna problemer. . Og det fører ikke nødvendigvis til at han ser på ham som en jevnaldrende.
Det er også, for ham, det er nok litt av det vi kan kalle en fast rolle. Noen ganger kommer folk inn i disse en-opp-en-ned-relasjonene. De blir liksom sittende fast på den måten, og de vil aldri tillate at rollene snus, og de vil ikke tillate at noen får respekt. Chuck ser ut til å holde Jimmy i en-ned-posisjonen: "Du er en som er en risiko, du er en som trenger å bli tatt vare på, du vil aldri ta vare på deg selv på en ansvarlig måte." Det har manifestert seg nå til et punkt hvor han i utgangspunktet neglisjerer bevisene på at Jimmy har det bedre, og han ignorerer det for å opprettholde forholdet sitt.
Det virket som Chucks ego virkelig kom i veien.
Jeg tror det er en stor del av det. Han vil se på det som en trussel for denne fyren som i utgangspunktet har vært en svindler før å nå være en likeverdig partner i noe han bygde. Det ville være en enorm trussel for ham.
Det er imidlertid kontrapunktet, [fordi] Chuck er avhengig av Jimmy for sin egen funksjon i forhold til hverdagen mens han er "syk", og om dette hjelper til med å opprettholde forholdet eller holder Jimmy nær. Det er alle slags ville hypoteser som kan utvikles, som at sykdommen faktisk er en måte å holde Jimmy i nærheten. Noen av det vi kan kalle psykosomatiske eller psykogene sykdommer, antas faktisk i visse terapiskoler å tjene en hensikt for personen. Noen ganger er det flukt fra jobb, noen ganger er det å spille den syke rollen og få noen andre til å ta seg av dem. Dette er en akseptabel måte for Chuck å bli tatt vare på, som ikke krever at han reduserer sin status som advokat. Alt dette er hypotetisk basert på det lille vi vet.
Jimmy er en ganske optimistisk person generelt. Hva tror du er fremtiden for Jimmy etter dette?
Jeg tror at han vil sprette tilbake, men det blir ikke på samme måte. En stund har han prøvd å tjene Chucks respekt. Nå skal han liksom avvise Chuck generelt, og nesten kaste babyen ut med badevannet. Han vil komme tilbake når det gjelder å gjøre det han vil, men det vil ikke være med et mål om å være respektabel i Chucks øyne. Vi har sett at gjennom sesongen, selv når han snakker om eldrelov, kan du se ham på en måte teste Chuck litt for å se om Chuck vil respektere det, og når han gjør det, ser det ut til at han føler en viss lettelse eller noen fordel av at.
Hvordan vil forholdet hans til Chuck utvikle seg herfra?
Hvis dette var et virkelighetsscenario, ville Chucks symptomer bli mye verre når Jimmy drar, forutsatt at hypotesen vi snakket om tidligere. Det ville blitt verre med det formål å trekke Jimmy tilbake. Hvis det ikke lykkes, kan det skifte til noe annet. Det vil avhenge av hva Jimmy gjør i den ligningen, og om han forblir engasjert på en eller annen måte. Jeg vet ikke at de ikke kan forenes, for det virker som de har hatt en nær forbindelse i lang tid.
La oss berøre Hamlin et øyeblikk. Hans ekstreme lojalitet til Chuck og til selskapet førte til at han holdt Jimmy i mørket om å bli ansatt i årevis. Hvordan kan folk ta en slik beslutning og holde seg til den?
Dette er gjetninger, fordi vi har et så lite vindu inn i ham, inn i hva som egentlig skjer bak kulissene med denne karakteren. Chuck er åpenbart eldre enn ham, så mye kan være et farsforhold og han ser etter godkjenning på den måten. Det kan også være at Chuck har overbevist ham om at dette er bra for maktstrukturen eller firmaet selv. Vi rasjonaliserer ting for å rettferdiggjøre hvilken oppførsel vi må gjøre av andre grunner.
Om det samme emnet vil jeg gå videre til Mike. Mike har en tale, som jeg tror reflekterer hovedtemaet forDu bør ringe Saul, der han snakker om å være en god kriminell, eller en dårlig god fyr. Det handler om å leve etter din egen moralske kode. Er dette en måte folk rasjonaliserer dårlig oppførsel?
Det er et moralsk utviklingssystem, og den andre til toppen er en slags tro på systemet som eksisterer. Den over som er å se gjennom systemet og kunne se hva sannheten er og hva fordeler og ulemper med det er. Chuck mener loven er hellig. Mike gjør det ikke. Mike har sett hvordan folk bøyer loven og hvordan den blir misbrukt. De viser forskjellige nivåer av moralsk utvikling mellom de to. Mike tror det, fordi han virkelig har sett de opplevelsene. Han tar tilsynelatende samvittighetsfulle valg om bruken av vold. På samme måte som Walter White gjør, rettferdiggjør han sin bruk av vold av det han mener er en høyere slutt, i motsetning til vold i voldsformål, som er hva en skurk kan gjøre.
FAQs
What is Chucks diagnosis in Better Call Saul? ›
One of the subplots of the show follows Chuck's obsessive compulsive order (OCD), a mental illness where people suffer from intrusive thoughts and compulsions.
What mental illness does Jimmy McGill have? ›Antisocial personality disorder
The arc of his character is carefully constructed to resist moralizing. Just as we start to make up our minds about Jimmy, a new side of him is revealed that's incompatible with that judgment.
Afterward, he confesses to Jimmy and Kim that he may be responsible for Chuck's death because he forced Chuck to retire after the increase in HHM's malpractice insurance premium.
What were Chuck McGill's last words to Jimmy? ›Ultimately, things reached a point where Chuck's final words to Jimmy were, "The truth is you've never mattered all that much to me." So, why didn't Jimmy solve the situation by telling this to Kim?
Is Chuck's Diagnosis real? ›While Chuck's condition is real in the sense that EHS is inspired by real life, it's certainly not real in the traditional sense. Like anti-vaccination and climate change being a hoax, EHS is the result of false information spreading and seizing advantage of those with existing psychological conditions.
Is Electromagnetic sensitivity a real thing? ›EHS is characterized by a variety of non-specific symptoms that differ from individual to individual. The symptoms are certainly real and can vary widely in their severity. Whatever its cause, EHS can be a disabling problem for the affected individual.
Does Jimmy have a split personality? ›The developer has stressed that Jimmy does not have Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID), formerly called Multiple Personality Disorder. The note about Jimmy and DID can be read on the game's main menu.
What mental illness does Walter White have? ›By examining the social and internal interactions of the character Walter White, it is clear that he could be clinically diagnosed with a narcissistic personality disorder.
Does Chuck McGill have psychosis? ›Last night's season finale took an extraordinarily dark turn with regard to that illness, as Chuck sinks into psychosis following his forced retirement from the law firm he built.
Why is Chuck so obsessed with Jimmy? ›Although in the first season it seemed that he was initially supportive of Jimmy, Chuck harbored resentful feelings toward him because of his conman past and charisma, in addition to Jimmy's approach to his career. From the second season onward, Chuck transforms into Jimmy's nemesis.
Why did Chuck betray Jimmy? ›
He believes that Jimmy with a law degree is dangerous and an insult to the legal profession, and rationalizes his conniving and betrayal as serving the greater good. Chuck later hatches a scheme to have his brother disbarred.
Do they ever find Howards body? ›Better Call Saul's eighth episode ended with Mike (Jonathan Banks) burying both Lalo and Howard's bodies in a shared grave in Gus' bunker meth lab. Looking back at a specific moment in Breaking Bad, fans believe it was Hank Schrader (Dean Norris) and his team who discovered their grave.
Did Jimmy ever love Chuck? ›Jimmy shows an absolute love for his older brother. After all, it was Chuck who helped Jimmy get out of trouble back in Chicago — when Jimmy defecated on top of a car in front of children, Chuck represented him as his lawyer. It was also Chuck who hired Jimmy to work at HHM's mailroom.
Why didn't Jimmy cry when Chuck died? ›It's classic denial. He told himself he didn't care, and acted like he didn't care, so he didn't have to deal with his own feelings.
What did Jimmy admit to Chuck? ›Desperate for Chuck to stop behaving erratically, Jimmy confesses to tampering with the Mesa Verde documents and bribing the copy store clerk to keep quiet. When Jimmy leaves, Chuck unveils a tape recorder he had activated prior to Jimmy's arrival.
Is Chuck's Electromagnetic Hypersensitivity real? ›The symptoms are real, but they are not caused by electromagnetic fields. Instead, they seem to be triggered by something far more mysterious: the nocebo effect.
Was Chuck's death accidental? ›Chuck's life ended at his own hand via an intentional house fire, but his presence certainly never left the Breaking Bad spinoff, continuing to make it better. The Better Call Saul Chuck death and life continued to shape Jimmy's Better Call Saul arc throughout the show's next few seasons.
Is it all in Chuck's head? ›However, the biggest question remains: Is Chuck's illness real or all in his head? "It's definitely real to Chuck," co-creator and executive producer Peter Gould tells TVGuide.com. "Chuck is maybe the smartest character on the show, and yet, he's trapped by this condition.
Do humans give off an electromagnetic field? ›Yes, all objects, including human bodies, emit electromagnetic radiation. The wavelength of radiation emitted depends on the temperature of the objects. Such radiation is sometimes called thermal radiation. Most of the radiation emitted by human body is in the infrared region, mainly at the wavelength of 12 micron.
Can EMF make you sick? ›According to WHO , extremely low frequency and radiofrequency EMFs are unlikely to cause any adverse health effects. You should feel safe using your cell phone and appliances. Power lines are also considered safe, as long as you keep a safe distance from them.
Do electromagnetic fields affect humans? ›
The main effect of radiofrequency electromagnetic fields is heating of body tissues. There is no doubt that short-term exposure to very high levels of electromagnetic fields can be harmful to health.
Why can't Jimmy go to the ground floor? ›Jimmy will only go to floors he can 'hide' in, so he will never hunt for Maya on the Ground Floor or Lower Level. If Jimmy sees Maya enter a room, or suspects she is inside, he will take a moment to pull out a key and unlock the door. If he fails to find Maya, he will leave.
Are Gene and Jimmy the same person? ›During the black-and-white scenes that took place after the Breaking Bad timeline, we see Jimmy managing a Cinnabon in Omaha, Nebraska under the alias of Gene Takovic.
What happens if Jimmy catches you? ›Unfortunately, you've really pissed off Jimmy (what with locking him in that room and all) and he's out for blood — if he catches you or your friends this time around, he won't just bonk you… he'll kill you. You'll also lose the option to save/quick save, so if you get got, you have to start all over again.
What is Jesse Pinkman's mental illness? ›Throughout Breaking Bad, Jesse finds himself constantly suffering as a result of his involvement in Walter's business. He's beaten, nearly killed multiple times, imprisoned, and suffers severe anxiety and depression as a result of his experiences.
What is the personality of a narcissist? ›Narcissistic personality disorder is a mental health condition in which people have an unreasonably high sense of their own importance. They need and seek too much attention and want people to admire them. People with this disorder may lack the ability to understand or care about the feelings of others.
Is Tuco A psychopath? ›Numerous characters in television shows are informally described as psychopaths. Examples include Natalie Buxton in Bad Girls, Sean Slater and Michael Moon in EastEnders, Dexter Morgan in Dexter, Tuco Salamanca in Breaking Bad and Better Call Saul, and Frank Underwood in House of Cards.
What mental disorders cause psychosis? ›Psychosis may be a symptom of a mental illness, such as schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, or severe depression. However, a person can experience psychosis and never be diagnosed with schizophrenia or any other disorder.
Was Chuck's condition psychological? ›Mental illness in this series is presented through the character Chuck, who, at the be- ginning of the series, is deemed to be of sound mind as his illness is purely physical, but whose reception is transformed as a result of his illness being irrefutably categorized as men- tal, a dichotomy common in the US (Mehta 14) ...
Is Chuck McGill a genius? ›Chuck is a highly intelligent and dedicated lawyer who views the law as being sacred, and is very determined in helping his clients in any way possible. He founded HHM with George Hamlin and George's son Howard, and is well respected by his colleagues at HHM and other prestigious law firms.
Why does Jimmy become gene? ›
Finally, "Gene Takavic" arises when Jimmy is forced to flee Albuquerque under a false name. Gene has been on his best behavior since debuting in Better Call Saul's opening scene.
Why was Jimmy happy after Chuck died? ›He wasn't distraught because he lost his brother and blamed himself for it; Chuck's death left him feeling empty and defeated because Chuck had the final say in their relationship, making clear where Jimmy stood by telling him, "You've never mattered all that much to me." These were the last words Chuck said to him, ...
How does Jimmy expose Chuck? ›Jimmy cross-examines Chuck, using Mike's photos of the interior of his house to question him about his state of mind at the time he taped Jimmy's confession. Jimmy further confronts Chuck about how close he has to be to an electrical object to be affected by his EHS.
How did Jimmy sabotage Chuck? ›Charles, a prestigious lawyer with a strange allergy to electricity, has long sabotaged Jimmy, his scam-loving younger brother who's been trying, trying, and trying to make good. Jimmy sabotaged him back by doctoring legal documents; Chuck then feigned a medical episode to get Jimmy to confess, on tape, to doing so.
Who is the villain of Better Call Saul? ›Don Eduardo "Lalo" Salamanca is a major antagonist in the Breaking Bad franchise, serving as one of the two main antagonists (alongside Chuck McGill) of Better Call Saul and a posthumous antagonist in Breaking Bad.
Why does Chuck not want Jimmy to be hired? ›The hearing room is arranged to accommodate Chuck's EHS and Howard Hamlin testifies that Chuck did not want to hire Jimmy as an attorney at HHM, supposedly to avoid the appearance of nepotism.
What happened to Kim Wexler? ›The ultracompetent attorney who married Jimmy McGill (Bob Odenkirk), the man most likely to bring out the shadier side of her character, never appears in Breaking Bad, which led some viewers to assume she would die before Saul finished its run. But as Monday's series finale confirmed, Kim Wexler lives on.
How did Kim and Jimmy drug Howard? ›The Howard Hamlin character impeachment scam was an elaborate scam orchestrated by Jimmy McGill and Kim Wexler to undermine Howard Hamlin by falsely portraying him as a cocaine addict, aiming to force an early settlement to the Sandpiper Crossing class-action lawsuit, in which Jimmy had a multimillion-dollar share.
Are Jimmy and Kim responsible for Howard's death? ›Kim is responsible for his downfall more than Jimmy was. She kept on with the plan and the plots to downgrade or tarnish the career of Howard, which eventually led to his death.
Why does Kim Wexler love Jimmy? ›Kim sees that Jimmy has the potential to be a proper, successful lawyer who can leave the ways of Slippin Jimmy behind (his earlier con-man alter ego). Kim thus makes a point of sticking up for Jimmy because she feels he is being unfairly characterized by everybody around him.
Did Chuck screw over Jimmy? ›
By effectively using his condition as a weapon against his brother, Chuck betrays all of the trust that Jimmy had placed in him and starts down a much darker path to destroy jimmy's career as a lawyer.
Why did Kim marry Jimmy? ›Kim tells Jimmy she is upset that he made her the "sucker" for his con and says that because of the lack of trust they either need to separate or get married so they can enjoy spousal privilege. Jimmy and Kim marry in a simple courthouse ceremony.
Why did Saul get 86 years? ›Kim attends the sentencing in Albuquerque, where Jimmy admits he lied so she would be present in person. He confesses to enabling Walt and admits his role in Chuck's suicide. He is sentenced to 86 years in prison, where he is revered by fellow inmates who recognize him as Saul.
Why did Kim cry when Jimmy read letter? ›Kim had a more "normal" reaction, taking the letter as a compliment, and this is evidenced in the following episode when she suggested Jimmy get counseling, noting his coldness. But Kim is still more affected by Chuck's words than the average person would be, and this could be due to her troubled childhood.
How does Saul get caught? ›He finally takes to hiding in a dumpster, trying to scramble for his phone to call Ed the Disappearer. But his luck seems to have run dry, and he fumbles everything he's holding. That's when the police find and capture him.
Did Jimmy feel sad when Chuck died? ›"My brother..." he begins, before dropping his glistening eyes to the table, mournfully. "My brother is dead." he continues, barely able to get the words out. It's a subtle moment in Bob Odenkirk's performance, but it speaks volumes about the guilt that Jimmy still feels for Chuck's death.
Why did Jimmy confess at the end? ›After spending years denying he had any love left for the man, the finale's biggest reveal was that Jimmy genuinely loved his brother and regretted how things ended up, and his moment of truth was towards himself in order to save his soul rather than someone else's.
Why did Saul confess in the end? ›However, as explained in Walter White's Better Call Saul finale scene, the ending is about regret. This is why Jimmy also confesses to the court about his involvement in pushing his brother Chuck to the brink of suicide, even though it technically had nothing to do with Jimmy's RICO case.
Is Chuck's disorder in Better Call Saul real? ›Quick Answer: While the condition of electro-hypersensitivity is something real people have reported suffering, there is no scientific evidence that supports it is physically happening. Likely, it is a psychomatic torment caused by a person believing in the condition.
What is electromagnetic hypersensitivity syndrome? ›Sensitivity to EMF has been given the general name “Electromagnetic Hypersensitivity” or EHS. It comprises nervous system symptoms like headache, fatigue, stress, sleep disturbances, skin symptoms like prickling, burning sensations and rashes, pain and ache in muscles and many other health problems.
Why did Chuck lie about his illness? ›
He feigns sickness and mental deterioration in order to emotionally pressure Jimmy into admitting he truly did commit a felony. He did it because he couldn't bear seeing his brother in such a poor state, but it was all just a show.
Does Chuck in Better Call Saul have schizophrenia? ›What he claims to suffer from is Electromagnetic hypersensitivity , but as you can see from the Wikipedia page, that is a “pseudomedical diagnosis”. In other words, he isn't really allergic to electric fields, as the show has made a plot point several times.
Is Chuck's electromagnetic hypersensitivity real? ›The symptoms are real, but they are not caused by electromagnetic fields. Instead, they seem to be triggered by something far more mysterious: the nocebo effect.
Was Chuck's condition all in his head? ›Chuck is taken to the hospital, and the doctor proves to Jimmy that Chuck's illness is psychosomatic.
What caused Chuck's sensitivity to electricity? ›The show hasn't said anything specific at this point, but given the evidence so far, Chuck might be part of a small group of people suffering from electromagnetic hypersensitivity. It's a set of physical symptoms blamed on radiation from wi-fi, cell phones, and other appliances that use electricity.
Is the electromagnetic spectrum harmful to humans? ›Higher-frequency EMFs, which include x-rays and gamma rays. These EMFs are in the ionizing radiation part of the electromagnetic spectrum and can damage DNA or cells directly.
Can humans sense electric fields? ›While animals and even human cells have long been known to sense and react to electric fields, the exact process by which cells detect electricity had been to some extent mysterious -- and the subject of ongoing research.
How does EMF affect the brain? ›It has been found that RF-EMF can induce changes in central nervous system nerve cells, including neuronal cell apoptosis, changes in the function of the nerve myelin and ion channels; furthermore, RF-EMF act as a stress source in living creatures.
Why did Jimmy change 1261 to 1216? ›And as a commenter observed after last week's episode, Jimmy rightly anticipated that Chuck would be too full of hubris to double-check his paperwork on Mesa Verde, thus enabling the scheme to switch out 1261 for 1216. Quid pro quo, Chuck has sized up his baby bro pretty well.
Why was Jimmy not sad when Chuck died? ›Jimmy was extremely upset about Chuck's death, until Howard took the blame — essentially exonerating Jimmy. The reason Jimmy felt bad is that, while he does have a good heart, he is also very selfish. He initially blamed himself for Chuck's death. But hearing Howard's explanation rejuvenated Jimmy.
Does Chuck have psychosis? ›
Last night's season finale took an extraordinarily dark turn with regard to that illness, as Chuck sinks into psychosis following his forced retirement from the law firm he built.
Was Chuck McGill a bad guy? ›Chuck McGill, Jimmy's brother, is a highly successful attorney and initially portrayed as an upright character with an aversion to electricity due to a rare physical and mental condition. However, as the show progressed, the character developed into an antagonist, leading to his eventual downfall.